The bishops鈥� true colors have at last been fully exposed. For weeks now, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, the lobbying arm of the Catholic Church, has been decrying the requirement from the administration that new insurance plans cover birth control. Using every pulpit and pundit available, they have denounced the administration鈥檚 rule because, they say, it will force religiously affiliated institutions 鈥� like hospitals and universities -- to pay to support insurance plans that cover a service the church views as a sin. (Houses of worship, it is important to remember, were exempt from the requirement.)
On Friday, the administration weighed in again, announcing that religiously affiliated institutions will not have to buy coverage that includes contraception. And, under the administration鈥檚 plan, these institutions won鈥檛 even have to tell their employees that there is insurance available. But 鈥� and this is a critical but 鈥� women at these institutions will get coverage. Insurance companies will be charged with reaching out and providing coverage, free of charge to the employees. In other words, women will in fact be able to get birth control coverage no matter where they work.
We at the 吃瓜直播 have a lot to say about what has happened 鈥� and in particular how the original requirement did not violate the religious liberty of religiously affiliated institutions. But that鈥檚 not the story here. The story is the bishops鈥� response to the administration. You might expect them to be mollified. They seem to have gotten what they wanted: religiously affiliated institutions will not have to pay for the coverage 鈥� or even talk about it. Well, if that鈥檚 what you expected, you鈥檇 be wrong.
Here鈥檚 what the bishops said in their statement:
The only complete solution to this religious liberty problem is for HHS to rescind the mandate of these objectionable services.
That鈥檚 right. According to the bishops, religious liberty means that no insurer could be required to cover contraception. According to the bishops, religious liberty means that insurance would not cover the service that 98 percent of American women 鈥� including Catholic women 鈥� use. (Not to mention that if 98 percent of women are using birth control, a lot of men are implicated as well.)
鈥淩eligious liberty,鈥� in effect, would mean that the bishops get to impose their views on the rest of us. That鈥檚 just not how the Constitution works.
In other words, as the bishops have made clear, the fight is not about religiously affiliated institutions. The fight is about birth control coverage in insurance, period 鈥� a basic health care service that we need to protect our health and plan our lives. These were the rights denied my mother鈥檚 generation. They will not be denied mine.
Learn more about birth control coverage: Sign up for breaking news alerts, , and .
Learn More 吃瓜直播 the Issues on This Page
-
Wisconsin Supreme CourtJul 2025
Civil Liberties
+2 Issues
State V. K.r.c.. Explore Case.State v. K.R.C.
This case asks whether a 12-year-old boy was in custody and entitled to Miranda warnings during a closed-door police interrogation by a school resource officer in the school building. The court of appeals held that he was not in custody, not entitled to Miranda warnings, and voluntarily incriminated himself. The 吃瓜直播鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative and the 吃瓜直播 of Wisconsin filed an amicus brief arguing that admitting the boy鈥檚 statements into evidence not only violated the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution but Article I, Section 8 of the Wisconsin Constitution, and urging the Wisconsin Supreme Court to rest its decision on the state charter to better protect Wisconsinites鈥� civil liberties. -
News & CommentaryJul 2025
Civil Liberties
Takeaways From The Supreme Court's Term. Explore News & Commentary.Takeaways from the Supreme Court's Term
This term was marked by sharp right turns in major civil rights cases, a mixed record on lower-profile cases, and mixed outcomes in an ascendant emergency docket -
News & CommentaryJul 2025
Civil Liberties
Privacy & Technology
As Ai Gains Power, We Must Push For Guardrails To Protect Civil Liberties. Explore News & Commentary.As AI Gains Power, We Must Push for Guardrails to Protect Civil Liberties
As AI increasingly makes decisions in hiring, policing, and social services, the 吃瓜直播鈥檚 Civil Rights in the Digital Age Summit focuses on promoting responsible AI design to ensure technology protects rights and serves justice for all. -
Press ReleaseJun 2025
Civil Liberties
+2 Issues
Aclu Statement: 2,100 Protests Take Place Nationwide. Explore Press Release.吃瓜直播 Statement: 2,100 Protests Take Place Nationwide
WASHINGTON 鈥� On June 14, more than five million people nationwide rallied at over 2,100 events across the country, condemning President Trump鈥檚 escalating abuses of power. The wave of protests, co-sponsored by the 吃瓜直播, Indivisible, and a coalition of labor, environmental, and human rights organizations, was the largest mass mobilization since President Trump鈥檚 return to office. People gathered everywhere 鈥� from Maine to Florida, Pennsylvania to Texas 鈥� to demonstrate that they are not intimidated by the un-American tendencies of this administration. 鈥淭oday鈥檚 protests are a resounding message that people across the nation will not be intimidated by President Trump鈥檚 fear tactics. Americans are brave, democracy loving people and will not sit idly by as the Trump administration feeds our Constitution into the shredder 鈥� nor will the 吃瓜直播,鈥� said 吃瓜直播 Chief Political & Advocacy Officer Deirdre Schifeling. 鈥淚n just five months, we have sued the administration dozens of times for their abuses of power, and we will continue to defend our rights. Protecting our democracy isn鈥檛 a partisan issue 鈥� it鈥檚 core to being American. We will use every tool we can, from litigation to legislation to powerful protests in the streets, to stop the unconstitutional actions of this administration and protect our rights.鈥� The day of action caps off a week of unprecedented encroachments on our civil rights. President Trump federalized National Guard troops against the wishes of California Gov. Gavin Newsom and deployed active-duty military to an American city to quell protests. ICE raids and detainments continue to terrorize immigrant communities across the country and ramped up in major cities like Philadelphia, New York, Chicago, Seattle, and Washington, D.C. Administration officials also forcibly ejected and handcuffed Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), the country鈥檚 most senior Latino leader, as he sought answers about the administration鈥檚 actions. These events underscore the urgency of organized people power to show solidarity with our communities and resist the Trump administration鈥檚 assault on civil liberties. Despite intimidation and violence, the people showed up. As 吃瓜直播 National Campaign Director for Immigration Anu Joshi told the crowd of over 100,000 at the No Kings flagship march in Philadelphia, 鈥淟ooking around at the thousands of people here with you 鈥� and the millions of people joining events like this across the country 鈥� it is clear to me that we cannot be silenced, and we are not afraid. When we know our rights and exercise them, when we protest, when we dissent, when we speak freely, when we act to protect our families, our friends and our neighbors, when we show up, we make progress for all of us.鈥�